Tuesday, 27 June 2017
Up-to-the-minute perspectives on defence, security and peace
issues from and for policy makers and opinion leaders.

     |      View our Twitter page at twitter.com/defenceredbox     |     


Dr Jeffrey Bradford, Director of Research, U K Defence Forum:

Others are better equipped to comment on the contributions Richard Holmes CBE made in the fields of the armed services, publishing and television. Speaking from
personal experience I met Richard Holmes when on an induction tour as I embarked on my PhD at the Royal Military College of Science, Shrivenham. I was introduced to
Richard, whom at the time shared an office with Keith Simpson (recent Special Advisor to Tom King at MoD at the time, now MP and an advisor to the Foreign Secretary). They sat me on a chair in front of their desks and fired a dozen questions at me. That evening I went home and on being asked as to how I found them spoke as I felt, "It is like the antiques roadshow on television - to say you have either one is a treasure, to have both is priceless".

During the following three years I knew Richard I was immensely impressed by his dedication to academic matters and to mentoring thinking on the evolution of British
Military Doctrine through civilian and military tutees. Richard's character and manner was always thoughtful and engaging and although a decade since I completed my
time in Shrivenham it seems like yesterday. 

Robin Ashby, Director General, U K Defence Forum

A couple of years ago I attended a lecture by Richard Holmes on Afghanistan (including the code of the Pashtuns) in Parliament. MPs often don't attend their own meetings, let alone anyone else's. This was packed. Some who are now Defence Ministers arrived on time but had to stand in the aisles of a packed house to be entertained, informed and to have their thought centres tickled.  He'll be a big miss.

Dr Peter Caddick-Adams, U K Defence Academy

Richard was one of my closest friends. I find the prospect of a Holmes-free world is utterly devastating. He'd successfully seen off cancer but with a knackered immune system (from chemotherapy), he was then snatched by pneumonia yesterday morning at 3am. I last saw him bright as a button and buoyant at the beginning of the week, so this is a cruel side-swipe over the otherwise joyous Royal Wedding weekend.

One of the finest tributes I've read so far is "I hope he has already been welcomed into the celestial Mess and is perched in an ethereal corner, clutching a fine, angelic vintage, embarking on his first discussion of strategy (of several million to come) with Oliver Cromwell, the Dukes of Marlborough and Wellington, Field Marshal Sir John French and Sir Winston Churchill, all subjects of his biographies. They couldn't ask for better company"

Jon Wort

A great shock. Richard was an inspirational individual who certainly brought military history to life and was probably the catalyst for a generation of Battlefield historians/tour guides/enthusiasts.

Keith Simpson MP

I was fortunate enough to be serving as Adjutant of 1 WESSEX during his tenure as Commanding Officer 2 WESSEX and I shall retain nothing but good memories of an outstanding officer, scholar and all together a person who touched many people's lives.I knew Richard Holmes from when he and I were colleagues together in the Department of War Studies at Sandhurst and later as co-directors at the Cranfield Security Studies Institute. Richard was a first class military historian, the author of many books and articles, a superb lecturer whether it was to senior officers on the Higher Command and Staff Course or to the local branch of the Western Front Association. But he was very much an "applied academic" who was a very active member of the TA and as the senior TA officer had a crucial input in the 1998 Strategic Defence Review. He will be sadly missed by all his friends. 

Dr Julian Lewis MP

Not only was he the archetypal scholar-soldier, Professor Holmes was a charismatic communicator of the first rank.

Julian Brazier MP

Richard Holmes was best known as one of the foremost military historians of the era. This remarkable man was also the first ever member of the Territorial Army to be the Director of Reserves and Cadets, a post hitherto held exclusively by members of the Regular Armed forces. On arriving in post at the same time as an incoming Labour government, one of his first tasks was to fight off powerful voices from within the Regular military and persuade ministers that a full Territorial Army should be retained, including combat units, rather reducing our reserves to a pool of specialists.

As an academic at Sandhurst and Shrivenham, he was an inspiration to a whole generation of rising officers, bringing the lessons of history alive in a fast-changing era.

See the BBC obituary www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk/13251220

Add comment

Security code

Latest from icasualties.org

  • PRI- Afghan boys escape sex slavery, but struggle to break out of role
    Adorned in makeup, fake breasts and bells, Jawed whirls around middle-aged men at Kabul's underground bacha bazi, or "boy play" parties, where the former child sex slave finds freedom of sorts as a dancing boy.
  • KP- Suicide bomber shot dead in Nangarhar province
    A suicide bomber was shot dead by the security forces before he manage to carry out an attack on the provincial officials. According to the local security officials, the incident took place early on Sunday in Ghani Khel district of Nangarhar.
  • AP- Marines rekindling old Afghan relations in Helmand Province
    In Afghanistan's turbulent Helmand province, U.S. Marines are rekindling old relationships and identifying weaknesses in the Afghan forces that the Trump administration hopes to address with a new strategy and the targeted infusion of several thousand American forces. Returning to Afghanistan's south after five years, Marine Brig. Gen. Roger Turner already knows where he could use some additional U.S. troops. And while he agrees that the fight against the Taliban in Helmand is at a difficult stalemate, he said he is seeing improvements in the local forces as his Marines settle into their roles advising the Afghan National Army's 215th Corps.
  • rferl- U.S. Joint Chiefs Chairman Makes Unannounced Visit To Afghanistan
    The chairman of the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff, the top-ranking U.S. military officer, has arrived in Kabul on a previously unannounced visit as Washington considers sending more troops to Afghanistan. General Joseph Dunford was due to meet with Afghan officials as well as U.S. and coalition leaders and troops during his visit, which was expected to last several days.
  • KP- Al-Qaeda member among 6 killed in Maidan Wardak airstrike
    At least six militants including a member of the Al-Qaeda terrorist network were killed in an airstrike in central Maidan Wardak province of Afghanistan, the Ministry of Defense (MoD) said Saturday.
  • AP- cautionary tales as US ponders Afghan boost
    One shirt, one pair of pants. Those are the basics for outfitting an Afghan soldier. But in that simple uniform combination are the threads of two troubling stories - one about the waste of millions in American taxpayer dollars, the other about the perils of propping up a partner army in a seemingly endless war.
  • AP- China aims to improve ties between Afghanistan, Pakistan
    China's foreign minister says Beijing will hold a dialogue with Afghanistan and Pakistan to help improve relations between the two South Asian neighbors. Wang Yi said during a visit to Pakistan on Sunday that foreign ministers from the three countries would discuss relations, with an emphasis on economic cooperation.
  • ToloNews- Two Security Incidents Noted On First Day Of Eid
    The first day of Eid-al-Fitr saw 10 security force members killed in an attack in Herat, while a suicide bomber died in Nangarhar before reaching his target...Two security incidents were recorded on Sunday, the first day of Eid-al-Fitr, which included a deadly Taliban attack on a check post near Salma Dam in Herat and a suicide bombing in Nangarhar.
  • ToloNews- 10 Security Force Members Killed Near Herat's Salma Dam
    Taliban attacked a security check post about 13kms from the dam killing the security force members and making off with their weapons, officials confirmed. At least 10 security force members were killed at a check post about 13kms from Salma Dam in western Herat province on Saturday night, officials said on Sunday.
  • ToloNews- 10 Security Force Members Killed Near Herat's Salma Dam
    Taliban attacked a security check post about 13kms from the dam killing the security force members and making off with their weapons, officials confirmed. At least 10 security force members were killed at a check post about 13kms from Salma Dam in western Herat province on Saturday night, officials said on Sunday.

British military casualties - Editorial policy

In the service of our country.

Eulogies for all personnel killed on UK operations in Afghanistan, Iraq and elsewhere are posted as soon as they have been released by the UK Ministry of Defence. Each eulogy we publish for men down in operations brings a lump to the throat. We are losing the best of the best. Politicians must ensure that, when the newspaper cuttings have faded, their sacrifice has had some meaning, has helped bring about a good result. Anything else would be a waste for which they will be eternally condemned.

There is invariably at least a 24 hour gap between the official release of news of an event and the naming of the dead. This is to allow families to be informed and proper eulogoies to be produced. Occasionally families request no euologies or comment. We abide by guidance we receive on such sensitive matters. We regret that information on those who sacrifice almost as much through grave injury is seldom released by the MoD for operational reasons, and so we are unable to pay tribute.


We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on the Defence Viewpoints website. However, if you would like to, you can modify your browser so that it notifies you when cookies are sent to it or you can refuse cookies altogether. You can also delete cookies that have already been set. You may wish to visit www.aboutcookies.org which contains comprehensive information on how to do this on a wide variety of desktop browsers. Please note that you will lose some features and functionality on this website if you choose to disable cookies. For example, you may not be able to link into our Twitter feed, which gives up to the minute perspectives on defence and security matters.